Pulp and paper giant dodges deforestation probe
On June 22nd 2013, the FSC announced that APRIL had asked its certification bodies to withdraw all of its FSC Chain of Custody (COC) certificates.(1)
The three environmental organisations had earlier lodged a complaint with the FSC that APRIL was in violation of FSC’s Policy for Association through its continued large-scale conversion of natural forests in Indonesia to plantations, including the destruction of high conservation value (HCV) forests. The company also has persistent social conflicts in its operations.
In a statement responding to FSC’s announcement, APRIL stated that its decision ‘not to hold or seek FSC CoC/CW certification for the foreseeable future is based on concerns about the FSC’s Policy for Association’. (2)
The FSC Policy for Association is in place to ensure that the FSC only associates with companies committed to fundamental principles of responsible forest management. It requires that a company holding FSC CoC certificates not be involved in the conversion of HCV forest and must not have converted an area of forest covering more than 10,000 ha within the past five years.
APRIL also holds COC certificates under the other major forest certification scheme, the Programme for Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC) However, the NGOs could not file a complaint to PEFC as it doesn’t have a Policy of Association.
“By quitting the FSC, APRIL is avoiding independent scrutiny of its operations as presented in the NGO’s formal complaint to the FSC. It is effectively admitting its deforestation practices are incompatible with the FSC” says Aditya Bayunanda from WWF Indonesia.
“Between 2007 and 2012, APRIL and its suppliers in Riau have converted close to 200,000 ha of Sumatra’s rainforests to plantations. Much of that was vital forest habitat for critically endangered Sumatran elephants and tigers.” (3)
“Companies like APRIL that are dependent on rainforest destruction are provoking social conflict through a failure to respect customary rights over land. Such operations are clearly unsustainable,” said Lafcadio Cortesi from RAN. “By walking away from the FSC, APRIL is sending a clear signal to the market that it has no intention of stopping its destructive operations. Contrary claims by APRIL are no more than greenwash.”
“APRIL is now the largest driver of deforestation for pulp in Indonesia. In 2012 alone, its suppliers planned to clear around 60,000 ha of rainforest,” said Zulfahmi from Greenpeace Southeast Asia. “Greenpeace is calling on any company buying from APRIL to cancel these contracts until APRIL finally cleans up its act and stops trashing rainforests.”
WWF, Greenpeace and RAN are calling on APRIL to immediately stop all natural forest clearance in all of its own and suppliers’ concession and commit to a comprehensive zero deforestation policy as first steps. The NGOs also call on the FSC to ensure that any company associated with deforestation, such as companies related to the Royal Golden Eagle (RGE) group of which APRIL is part, are not allowed to hold FSC certificates.
Notes to Editor:
1. FSC announcement on APRIL:
2. APRIL statement: www.aprilasia.com/images/pdfs/APRIL%20comment%20on%20withdrawal%20from%20FSC%20by%20associated%20companies%20-%2024%20June%202013.pdf
3. Interactive map of includes data on deforestation and APRIL suppliers’ concessions:
http://maps.eyesontheforest.or.id The mapping is a collaboration between Eyes on the Forest (coalition between WWF-Indonesia, Jikalahari and Walhi Riau) and Google Earth Outreach
4. In FSC Policy of Association, failure of the 10,000 ha forest conversion threshold does not lead to disassociation per se, but leads to a case by case investigation by an independent Complaints Panel, as the one asked by the 3 NGOs, taking into account the local circumstances, the scale of the operation and plans for continued conversion.
WWF-Indonesia , Aditya Bayunanda GFTN & Pulp Paper Manager, email: firstname.lastname@example.org, phone: +62 818265588
Greenpeace, Tristan Tremschnig, Communications Coordinator Indonesia Forests, email: email@example.com, phone: +31 6 43 78 7393 (Netherlands),
Rainforest Action Network, Lafcadio Cortesi, Asia Director, email : Lcortesi@ran.org, phone : +1-510-701-3540