NGOs call on Banks not to Fund Large Dam and Smelter Project in Iceland
If built, the Kárahnjúkar project will consist of nine dams, three reservoirs, a series of tunnels and river diversions, and a 690 megawatt power plant. It is only the first in a series of large new dam projects in Iceland·s highlands that are supposed to power new aluminum smelters. ·Kárahnjúkar will destroy unique environmental treasures on Iceland·s Eastern Highlands - the second largest remaining wilderness area in Western Europe·, says Arni Finnsson of the Iceland Nature Conservation Association (INCA).
Alcoa is closing smelters in other parts of the world and is moving to Iceland as part of a cost-saving strategy. The company is interested in tapping Iceland·s cheap electricity, and will not have to pay for the CO2 emissions of its new smelter because Iceland has an exception under the Kyoto protocol. ·It is unacceptable to sacrifice a large, pristine wilderness area for producing cheaper aluminum·, says Peter Bosshard of International Rivers Network (IRN). ·In its 2001 Vision Statement, Alcoa aspires to become ·the best company in the world·. Developing the Kárahnjúkar project would clearly be at odds with such a claim.·
Iceland·s National Power Company intends to raise funds for the Kárahnjúkar project from the European Investment Bank (EIB), the Nordic Investment Bank (NIB) and private banks. INCA, IRN, the CEE Bankwatch Network, Friends of the Earth International and WWF·s International Arctic Programme have today called on the EIB, the NIB and all banks that have funded the National Power Company in the past not to provide any funds for the Kárahnjúkar project. The NGO appeal was endorsed by 120 organizations from 47 countries.
·Financial institutions such as the EIB that claim to be environmentally sensitive should not give a penny to this disastrous project·, says Magda Stoczkiewicz of the CEE Bankwatch Network, who monitors the European Investment Bank with Friends of the Earth/International. ·NGOs will continue to follow the Kárahnjúkar project, and will hold any financial institution that puts money into it accountable for irreparable environmental damage.· Samantha Smith of WWF's International Arctic Programme, said: "We hope that the Kárahnjúkar proposal is the last time we see such an environmentally irresponsible power development plan see the light of day. What Iceland needs are plans to protect its environment - not destroy it."
Background on the Kárahnjúkar project:
If built, the Kárahnjúkar project will have massive environmental impacts on Iceland·s fragile Eastern Highlands wilderness area. It will irreparably damage a rare oasis of highland vegetation, and will destroy or severely impact sensitive habitats for the pinkfooted goose and other rare birds, salmonids, seals, and reindeer. The project·s Environmental Impact Assessment was rejected by Iceland·s National Planning Agency, a decision that was later overruled by the Minister for Environment.
The economic benefits of the Kárahnjúkar project for Iceland are questionable. The National Power Company·s assumptions regarding cost and time overruns and aluminum price trends are optimistic. A thorough economic evaluation commissioned by INCA estimates that (under its slightly different previous parameters) Kárahnjúkar will entail annual losses for Iceland of $36 million.
The Kárahnjúkar project is a highly politicized undertaking, and a divisive issue within Iceland. Three Icelandic citizens and INCA sued the Minister for Environment for overturning the negative decision on the project·s Environmental Impact Assessment. Iceland·s Courts of Law will consider this case in early April. In addition, INCA and an Icelandic citizen filed complaints with the EFTA Surveillance Authority regarding an infringement of the European Economic Area Agreement, asserting that the Icelandic Government unduly subsidizes electricity and aluminum production through a variety of measures.
The Kárahnjúkar dam and a 40 kilometers headrace tunnel from the reservoir to the powerhouse will be built by Impregilo of Italy. Six international consortia recently pre-qualified to submit bids for the electro-mechanical contracts of the project.